West Side Rentals
“ALLENMORE” BEACH HOUSE ON DONEGAL BAY
37525 Lakeshore Road. Allenmore is steps to a sandy beach with crystal clear water. Enjoy spectacular sunsets and view of 3 islands. Within walking distance are Mt. Pisgah, Hidden Valley Trail, nearby Kuebler Ross Trail. Town is a short bike ride away. The home has 4 bedrooms (1 Queen, 2 full, 4 single) and 2 full baths. Towels provided. A well stocked kitchen, washer and dryer. Outdoor shower, gas grill, charcoal grill and Solo fire pit. WiFi and TV. 3 SUPs and 2 kayaks (must sign liability waiver). Rental is Sunday (check in 2pm) to Sunday (check out 10am). $2,400. 1/2 due at signing, remainder 3 mos before arrival. Strict limit 8 people. Owners live on island. Contact Anna (708) 955-3957 or Dave (630) 853 6410.
View Web Page
BECKY’S SUNDOWN SHORES
3 bedroom 2 Bath open concept home on Lake Michigan with incredible Sunset Views! Private Lake Michigan cottage with beautiful sunsets, and nature at your doorsteps. 100 feet of Lake MI frontage with an outstanding Western View. New owners updating everything! 1,400 sq ft with 3 bedrooms (2 queen beds, 2 twin beds) and 2 full baths newly updated! Deck on Lake side with outside seating, picnic table and a fire pit. Just a bike ride from town. WIFI, smart TVs, DVD player, washer/dryer, dishwasher, microwave, coffee maker, fully equipped kitchen. Outside gas grill too. Linens and bath towels provided (BYO beach towels). No smoking and no pet policy. This home has everything you need to have a relaxing vacation! PLEASE NOTE: Best suited for 6 people (anymore require owner’s approval) and it rents Friday to Friday! Rate: $260/night. Plus sales tax and $200 cleaning fee. Email Nicole at nicolesundownshores@gmail.com
View Web Page E-mail
BIRD’S NEST
Enjoy spectacular sunsets at this spacious Donegal Bay home. Designed as a year round residence, amenities abound. Beautiful cherry wood flooring, wood burning stove, screened in porch, and multiple decks. This home boasts 4 Bedrooms (1 King, 2 Queens, and a daybed with a trundle), 2 Full Bathrooms, and a washer and dryer. Bird’s Nest has a fully equipped kitchen, TV, DVD, WiFi, books, games, and a few DVDs. Outside there are multiple decks to relax on, and a well established fire-pit on the sandy beach with plenty of beach chairs. This home is ideally situated near many of the island birding trials for leisurely day hikes. Please see our website for additional information.
(812) 320-8206
View Website E-mail
BLUE SPRUCE COTTAGE
** Just Listed** Tucked amidst the woods, just a stone’s throw from the shores of Donegal Bay, is where you’ll find this charming cottage. With a screened in porch of your dreams! Enjoy being serenaded by the harmonious blend of the forest and the waves crashing the shore! A haven for hikers, offering convenient access to Kuebler Trail, Hidden Valley Trail, and a short walk to McCauley’s Point beach access. Offering: 3 bedrooms, loft, sleeps 6-8, 2 full bathrooms, propane grill, fire pit with seating, smart TV/DVD/ Wi-Fi, washer/dryer, and much more!!! Please feel free to reach out with any and all questions! My name is Sarah Siller, I’m a fulltime Beaver Island Resident here to help you before and throughout your stay! (517) 672-2334
IslandPropertyServicesIPS@gmail.com BeaverIslandPropertyServices.com
View Web Page E-mail
BLYMY RODE
Blymy Rode is located on Donegal Bay and is the perfect spot for summer relaxation. Wide decks surround the house for expansive views of Lake Michigan and spectacular sunsets. Swim all day at the private beach and enjoy the stars under bonfire at the beach. It is a 3- bedroom, 2- full bath, house that sleeps 8: 2 bedrooms with queen beds, 1 bedroom with twin beds and a pullout couch that sleeps 2. Fully equipped kitchen that includes dishwasher, microwave, full size coffee maker, dishes, glasses, silverware, pots and pans. Includes: washer/dryer, gas grill, WiFi, Smart TV, DVR and movie library. We provide pillows and blankets, you need to bring sheets, pillowcases and towels for the bathroom, kitchen and beach. Firepit available for bonfires. Non-smoking, pet free. June-September and off-season rates available.
Contact: lymyrode@gmail.com (773) 391-1133.
View Web Page E-mail
BUTTERFLY BEACH – DONEGAL BAY
Resting on beautiful sandy Donegal Bay this home offers spectacular sunsets daily while being close to town. Swim in Lake Michigan, walk the bay after you have climbed Mt. Pisgah, hike nearby Kuebler Trail or Hidden Valley Trail. Our location is close to Donegal Bay bike trail, Barney’s Lake Nature Preserve and all the amenities of the town of St. James. Relax in this 3 bedroom home. 2 bedroom’s have Queens, 1 has a set of twins. Open floor plan allows for relaxation and visiting while cooking in a full equipped kitchen. Coffee maker, Microwave, pots, plates etc…everything you need to make this your home away from home. Wifi and smart TV, games, books, DVD with tapes for relaxing. Enjoy our wrap around deck which has a picnic table, chairs, grill while you create memories to last a lifetime. Once the sunset is ended watch the Island’s amazing night sky unfold relaxing under a canopy of a thousand stars. Build a fire in our outdoor fire pit and get the smore ingredients ready. No need to bring towels or sheets- they are provided. We love well behaved pets. Contact the owner about your pet for additional information. Non Smoking. Rents Saturday to Saturday for 1200 a week from June 1st to Labor Day weekend. Off season rates available. Contact Lisa Gillespie at (231) 632-4785 or email Lisag@tds.net.
View Web Page E-mail
CAMP MIGINI (formerly known as TAYLOR’S CAMP)
Beautiful home Located at 32143 Mrs. Reddings Trail. The home has an open floor plan with windows and sliders on the lakeside to the deck. Secluded, quiet location. With over 200′ of Lake Michigan frontage (It’s like having your own private beach) 2 bedrooms on the main floor with 2 full baths and 1 bedroom upstairs with an additional half bath. High end kitchen with all the amenities you need just like home! Fireplace, Gas Grill, dishwasher, Internet, TV, Dish, Linens, Bath towels, washer & dryer. Sleeps 6 possibly 8 with small children. No Smoking and NO pets For additional fee there is also an apartment above the garage that sleeps 4; 1 queen bed, 1-Futon, 1 bath and it’s own kitchen. Weekly Rate for House – $2,200 , plus cleaning fee./week (Full weeks only during Peak Season) (4 night minimum non-peak season). $725./week for Apartment. Rents from Saturday to Saturday.week plus sales tax & cleaning fee. For reservations please contact: drp.1124@gmail.com
View Web Site E-mail
COTTAGE ON KUEBLER
Beautiful cottage located at 36675 Allens Lakeview Rd. It’s on the west side of Beaver Island, quietly sits in the woods right next to Kueblers Walking Trail, 4.1 miles from town and walking or biking distance to the beautiful Donegal Bay Beach. Cottage sleeps 9 – 3 bedrooms with queen size beds – 1 small crib room with twin bed. The loft area has 2 fold out cots for children – 2 full baths. Full size kitchen. Amenities include: Fireplace, Washer & Dryer, Free Wi-Fi, Charcoal Grill, Towels & Linens, Weekly rental $950.00. Contact Erin at (231) 448-3355
View Web Page E-Mail
DEERWOOD LODGE
Deerwood Lodge is located on the Western shore of the island on 16 private wooded acres surrounded by conservation land on all sides. It is approximately 3 miles from town. The main levels of Deerwood boast over 8,500 square feet of living space with 6 bedrooms with private baths, a large great room with fireplace, formal and casual dining spaces, a professional kitchen, a three season room, and much more. The finished basement features a home theater and the Shipwreck Bar. The grounds of Deerwood Lodge include a two tier deck for enjoying the view of High Island and spectacular sunsets, 1,000 feet of private beach frontage, access to miles of hiking trails, and close proximity to Barney’s Lake. Deerwood Lodge provides the perfect setting for your island retreat and is great for large groups, multiple families, weddings and corporate meetings and retreats. Deerwood sleeps 18 guests and rents for $6,5000 per week in peak season (Saturday to Saturday). Off-peak rates are also available. Deerwood is a no-pet, no smoking home and grounds. Additional information and current availability can be found on the website: www.deerwood.net For more information and to make reservations please contact Meg at mebersoldt@eplusa-arch.com or call (314) 494-1435.
View Website E-Mail
DONEGAL BAY WATERFRONT COTTAGE
Moved from its original location in the harbor, this cottage has it all- space, charm, and waterfront on Donegal! 3bd/2bath, sleeps 8+, rents Sat-Sat for $2,400 per week July/Aug and $2,100 Sept/Oct. Available for rent as of July 26, 2025. Pictures are out of date (pre-move), but will update as soon as possible.
Please inquire by email to Trish Watson (Please add Beaver rental for the subject)- pwatsonrealty@gmail.com
View Web Page E-mail
DONEGAL WAVEFRONT
Experience beautiful Lake Michigan sunsets at “Donegal Wavefront,” one of only a few summer homes available on scenic Donegal Bay. Wavefront sleeps eight easily with the extra comfort of two and a half baths. It is located on the west side of Beaver Island, just 3.5 miles from town. The master bedroom, with a queen size bed affords a gorgeous view of Lake Michigan from a private deck. Three other bedrooms feature twin beds, complete with pillows and blankets. The galley style kitchen, Telephone, Washer/Dryer, DVD, SMART TVS and WIFI will add to your family fun. Wavefront is no smoking, PLEASE. This lovely home rents for $1,800 per week (Saturday to Saturday). For more information or to make reservations, email Renay at: BIWAVEFRONT@GMAIL.COM or call (917) 770-7907.
View Web Page E-mail
DRIFTWOOD
This beautiful home has an open floor plan and sits in the heart of Donegal Bay with 155 feet of sandy beach. No need to drive to a beach when it’s right in your front yard! Enjoy the views of the outer Islands from the sunroom or out on the decks. This is a 4 bedroom home that sleeps 8: 2 queen beds, 3 twins and a day bed. 2,860 square feet of living space, 2¼ miles from town. Fireplace, ceiling fans in all rooms, Laundry room with washer and dryer, Fully equipped kitchen, 2 full baths and 2 half baths; Linens and bath towels provided. Master suite is on the Lower level with 3 bedrooms on the upper level. Outdoor furniture, Gas grill, Satellite TV, DVD player, Wifi and Beautiful Sunsets. Rental fee is $2,950 plus fees & tax per week (Sunday to Sunday). 3 night minimum stay May, September, and October. Call for rates for parties exceeding 8 and also for Special Events! NO PETS & NO SMOKING.
View Web Page E-mail
INDIAN POINT OF VIEW
We have a very nice and well-maintained home on the northwest tip of Beaver Island. Indian Point of View is a beautiful place to view Whiskey, Squaw, and Garden Islands. Our home on the island is 1500 sq ft including 2 bedrooms and a loft with a murphy bed. It sleeps 6 adults with an additional pull-out for children. Internet is available. If this interest you, please visit our website for further details including all the pictures and information you will need, as well as contact information, if you are interested in renting. A calendar is available on the website to check availability. Our website is indianpointofview.com.
View Website
THE SANDPIPER HOUSE
Cozy and peaceful home for rent on Donegal Bay. This 2 bedroom get away has all the amenities you need for a relaxing vacation. Can accommodate up to 4 persons. Fully functional kitchen with all you need to create and enjoy a meal. The outdoor deck with gas grill and lots of seating, allows spectacular, unobstructed views of Lake Michigan. Whether you just want to enjoy the clean, fresh air, or view the magnificent sunsets, plenty of room is available. Just a short distance to the water and miles of beach, bike trails or town where you can take in kayaking, fishing, groceries and local delicacies. Home also has full sized washer and dryer as well as cable and internet. Plenty of beauty to see on the island as well, should you want to explore. Amenities include bikes, kayaks, beach towels, and linens so you can enjoy your staycation! It rents Friday to Friday – Check in 3…check out 10. $1575 June- Labor Day. Contact us for off season rates.
Contact Nicole wildranch2022@gmail.com
View Web Page E-mail
THE SANDY OWL
If you would like to trade the demands of modern life for a simpler existence on Beaver Island, this is your chance! Stop in town for groceries and snacks, and spend a week or two on the beach. Located on Donegal Bay all you need to bring is your sunscreen, and swimsuit. Built in 1985 as a cabin on the beach, the Sandy Owl’s current owners have preserved the original feel of this quirky two open-bedroom, one full bath cabin. Excellent view of the sunset from inside or on the deck, or stroll a few feet down to the beach! If you are the type of person who needs a dishwasher while on vacation, this is not the place for you. However, the cabin does have everything you need to cook a great meal. The Sandy Owl rents Saturday to Saturday for $1800, dogs stay for free with a $200 deposit, because what is vacation on the island without your trusty companion? The rental fee includes towels, linens, and cleaning services. This cozy cabin has a limit of 6 people. Contact Nicole at wildranch2022@gmail.com
View Web Page E-mail
TRAILS END
** NEW Listing** Trails End is conveniently situated just 2 miles away from town, a mere half a mile from Font Lake where the call of the Loons echoes through the air, and a short 1 mile from Donegal Bay Beach. It’s the perfect spot to indulge in all your favorite outdoor activities, whether it’s walking, hiking, kayaking, fishing, swimming, boating, bird watching, or even star gazing. This charming home is bursting with character and offers a warm and inviting retreat. With 3 bedrooms and a spacious loft nestled above the living room, it comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. With 1.5 bathrooms, and a luxurious jetted tub located in the second bedroom! No matter the season or the weather, this vacation rental has got you covered! From the expansive screened-in porch and ample loft and living room areas to the covered front porch adorned with multiple rocking chairs, every corner of this place is designed for relaxation. So go ahead, treat yourself to that dream vacation and unwind at Trail’s End. Linens, pillows, towels, and toiletries are all included. And that’s not all! We also offer Wi-Fi, TV, a DVD player, games, a fire pit, a grill, and so much more! Please feel free to reach out with any and all questions. My name is Sarah Siller I’m a fulltime Beaver Island Resident here to help you before and throughout your stay!
(517) 672-2334 BeaverIslandPropertyServices.com
View Web Page Email
THE WILD GOOSE
A 20 minute drive from St. James takes you to The Wild Goose, a 12 acre, family-owned property with over 600’ of private Lake Michigan beach. This beautiful, custom built home sits on the Western shore with spectacular sunset viewing. High Island can be seen 3 miles off shore and there are 20 steps down to the beach. Kitchen is full-sized, fully stocked, laundry, 1.5 baths, large TV, DVD, movies, books, 2 bikes, 2 SUP’s, beach chairs, grill, beach bonfire pit. The main house sleeps a maximum of 6 people, $3,150/wk peak season, $350 per night off peak. Additional guest house, with additional full bath, can also be rented to sleep up to 4 additional people for $1,200/wk. Contact Dan and Sarah Cooper danandsarahcooper@yahoo.com
View Web Page E-mail