Harbor Area Rentals

Allure of the Pines is located on Font Lake. This is a 4 bedroom, 2 bath home that sleeps eight in 3 queen size beds and 1 set of twins. Walk-out basement opens to lake side. The kitchen and dining area are encased by large windows and overlook Font Lake. Beaver Island loons can be heard from the deck while enjoying the beautiful lake view. Sheets and towels are not provided, but amenities include wi-fi, roku, apple tv, fully equipped kitchen w/ dishwasher,washer & dryer, screened-in porch, rowboat ,kayak and dock. The township park is nearby with a convenient bike path leading into the town of St. James (about 1 mile away ). Two popular Lake Michigan beaches are nearby, Donegal Bay on the island’s west side and the Public Beach on the east side in Paradise Bay . $1,250.00 per week. (231) 448-2615 View Web Page  E-mail

Clean and cozy two-bedroom cottage sleeps 6 (one bedroom has a double bed, the other has twin beds, and a pull-out queen couch in living room). It’s located on a private beach with a lovely view of the harbor and its activity, just 4 blocks from town/boat dock. It has a fully equipped kitchen, very nice living room furniture, satellite TV, charcoal grill, picnic tables, and beach fire pit. The shallow water out in front makes it perfect for small children. Please No pets or smoking at the cottage. Off season rates available, two night minimum. Prior to mid-June rates are $750 per week. Again, after Labor Day, rates are $750 per week. From mid-June to Labor Day rates are $900 weekly, Saturday to Saturday. To make your reservation, please email Marijean at pikedut@yahoo.com or you may call or text Marijean (231) 740-8551. View Web Page E-mail

You can truly put yourself “At Leisure” while staying at this awesome cabin just a short walk from the Whiskey Point Light. This cabin is located on Lake Michigan at the mouth of the Harbor.  It features two bedrooms and sleeps six- one queen size bed and two twin beds plus a sleeper couch. This setting is perfect for kids; has a large yard plus the beach.  Amenities include a charcoal grill, fire pit on the beach, TV/VCR, CD player, washer/dryer, beautiful fieldstone fireplace, iron and ironing board, coffee maker, microwave, full kitchen. (Sorry – no dishwasher.) No smoking or pets.  Linens are provided.  Enjoy spectacular morning vistas on the deck and watch the boats as they enter Paradise Bay. Enjoy the feeling of isolation while staying a short walk from town. On your way to the lighthouse, you can stop at the Toy Museum, buy fresh whitefish at the Beaver Island Fish Market or visit the Maritime Museum. Heading east, it is a short walk to the Gull Harbor Nature Preserve.  Keep your eyes open – you may spot a bald eagle!  Weekly rentals are Sunday to Sunday – $775 for May and September and $825 for June, July and August. Four-day minimum stays can be arranged for the off-season.  Please contact Renee Rosema at (231) 828-4185 or email Rosema455@hotmail.com. View Web Page  E-mail

A view of the bay is worth the stay!  A breath-taking view (180°) of the beaver island harbor (Paradise Bay) overlooking the entire village of St. James.  Complete with a full front deck for watching the sail boats enter the harbor and front row seats to Lake Michigan’s most stunning sunsets. Weekly rates: $750 $1050.  Over-looking Beaver Island’s main harbor (180°) – 3 bedroom house, sleeps 6 – 1 bedroom lower w/twins and master bathroom with shower – 2 bedrooms upper with twins and bathroom with tub – Fireplace, pot-belly stove – Front and rear decks with deck furniture – Weber Charcoal grill – Fully equipped  kitchen (microwave, coffee-maker, toaster ,dishes, pots, and pans) – Linens included – Satellite Television, DVD, stereo system  CD – In town, overlooking bay, minutes to shopping, stores, and ferry dock. Call today to reserve your week in Northern Michigan’s emerald Isle. Contact Keith (978) 340-0077 or  keith_pierson@hotmail.com
View Web Page E-mail

Waterfront Home on Paradise Bay, The Emerald Isle’s Harbor. Our Three bedroom, two bath home sites on Paradise Bay, the natural harbor of Beaver Island. Towels and Linens are included and we have a washer and dryer along with all new appliances and plenty of room for the family or friends. Incredible view of the harbor and Lake Michigan from the many decks that let you relax in the sun with a spectacular view you usually can only get from a lighthouse! Outside on 5 acres, we’ve got a fire pit, a pickleball court, lots of room for yard games and a great beach! You’ll be in a great spot. Its just a short bicycle ride to town or short paddle to little Sand Bay Nature Preserve. Your rental includes Kayaks and standup paddleboards to explore the shoreline, and we also have also have paddleboard&jetski rentals available through Beaver Island Boat Rentals. 2100 weekly, 700 weekends throughout the year except June 15th-September1st. Not available for the following dates July 21-27, and August 18-24th. Call (231) 4482726 or (231) 459-6688. Website

Four Bedroom, 2 1/2 bath home on beautiful Beaver Harbor with 235.5 ft of sandy beach frontage with panoramic views of the whole Harbor, its entrance, Whiskey Point Lighthouse and wonderful sunrises and reflective sunsets. This 2000 sq. ft. home has a large front lawn for family play in addition to a secluded sandy beach. Gorgeous views with ample windows in the kitchen and living areas. The elevated deck is great for entertaining and offers another commanding view of the harbor light and the Beaver Island Ferry entering and leaving the harbor. The master bedroom/bathroom is located on the lower level, with a balcony deck on the lakeside. The location is ideal. Walking distance to Donegal Danny’s Pub and Restaurant and a quick bike-ride to all that Beaver Island’s downtown has to offer. Being on the harbor also offers calmer waters, so bring your paddle boards and kayaks. For 2020 fall season rates contact Ryan Wojan. Weekly rates for 2021 are 1650.00 a week.  Contact: ryan@smithrealtygaylord.com, (312) 545.8596. View Web Page E-mail

The Convent is a special getaway with breathtaking views, spectacular sunrises and sunsets. A “stone’s throw” away from the public beach and playground and is situated on a huge expansive lawn overlooking the beautiful harbor. The convent is short walking distance to the Island’s restaurants, pubs, shops, Community Center, the municipal marina and the ferry dock.There are “Eight” beautifully remodeled bedrooms. One Queen bedroom and one full size bath on the first floor that is ADA Accessible. The second floor has three rooms with Queen beds and four rooms with (2) twin beds in each room. There are also two full (newly remodeled) baths on the second floor. We provide linens, bath towels, pillows, and blankets. Downstairs, the kitchen is completely equipped with all the necessary cooking and eating accessories, including Microwave, Oven, Double Oven, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, and two coffee makers. This floor has a large dining room and a spacious living room, The living room is equipped with Satellite Smart TV and internet. The paved deck contains a grill, lawn chairs, and large picnic table.Open year round, minimum of one week peak season (Memorial Day to October 15th) and minimum of 3 night stay during slow season (October 16th to Memorial Day).  Peak Season (Memorial Day to October 15): $2900.00 per week — Security Deposit of $800 Off Peak (October 16 to Memorial Day): $1750.00 per week + Security Deposit of $800 Off Peak Nightly (October 16 to Memorial Day): $275.00 per night (3-night minimum) + Security Deposit of $400.00 For more information Call Us at (231)242-3125  web page  or E-mail

This vacation home overlooks Font Lake. The cabin sleeps seven with a full bath and a half bath upstairs. There is a satellite dish and Wi-Fi. The home is located on Donegal Bay Road one mile from town and 300 yards from the bike path. A sun porch overlooks the lake. A fishing boat with a motor is provided. Bikes are included. Two hundred feet to the east are sand dunes surrounding a lagoon off Font Lake. It is perfect for sun bathing and swimming if the beavers have not blocked off the inlet. Bring your own bed linens and towels. The fee is $850 per week with a $300 deposit. Call (479) 957-5528 or email at ldryan1934@gmail.com for contract and details.
View Web Page E-mail

Wonderful home in town that sleeps 6-8 comfortably. Home is set back from Kings Highway right after Holy Cross church. The home is nestled in the trees set back from the road that will keep you cool on a warm summers day and with no noise from traffic. It has a peekaboo view of the Paradise Bay and is close to everything. In a couple of minutes you can walk to the beach, library, Daddy Franks, restaurants etc.. Enjoy the beauty of the Island, the town of St. James and watch the sunrise from your porch for a great price. Beautiful big deck that gets lots of sun all day to relax and cook out and watch our amazing Dark Sky nights. Grill included for great summer cookouts and creating memories with your family. The home has a great open floor plan with fully equipped kitchen, dishwasher, microwave, and coffee maker.The home has free Wi-fi and a washer and dryer in the basement. The beautiful wood interior has two bedrooms downstairs. One with a Queen bed, another with a full. The full bath downstairs is handicap accessible along with the entrance that has a ramp. Great aspect if needing access for somebody that needs this type of accommodation. Upstairs has a enclosed loft with 3 twin beds and another full bath. No pets. Owner doesn’t allow smoking indoors but will allow it outside on the deck. This clean, beautiful, well kept getaway home is priced to make your vacation affordable. Only 900 a week if you bring linens, or 950 if the owner supplies them. Rents Saturday to Saturday in full season. Check in 3:00 p.m. , check out 10:00 a.m. After Labor Day contact owner for fall deals and options with flexibility to enjoy the Islands beautiful fall colors. Contact Carol Gillespie at (231) 675-4211. View Web Page  Email

In town sleeps 8/10. 3 full bath home. $1,500.00 week plus cleaning deposit. Use of vehicle for $200.00 deposit. (231) 547-4046 evening (231) 547-6600. View Web Page E-mail

Brand new rental in 2019. Home has been completely remolded! In town around the corner from Daddy Franks next to Ed Wojan’s office. Huge kitchen and Livingroom, family room in basement, 2 bathrooms, and 5 bedrooms! Sleeps 12. Nice deck for relaxing and grilling. Close to everything. Walk to the public beach, museum, and restaurants. $1850.00 per week.Contact Tina Drost at bisland352@gmail.com or call (231)881-2589. View Web Page E-mail

Stunning views of Paradise Bay! Come and stay with us in this luxurious loft overlooking the harbor. You will enjoy having a birds eye view of harbor activity, and a great spot for birding. This loft is a two bedroom apartment located on the second floor above the Erin Motel. Just half a block from the Beaver Island Boat Company, you could plan your Hike & Bike vacation. There is a laundry facility for your convenience. LINENS PROVIDED ~ 2 Bedrooms with Queen size beds ~ 1 Bathroom ~ Fully equipped kitchen with coffee maker, toaster oven ~ TV/DVD/WIFI ~ Washer and Dryer available for guests use ~ No pets allowed. Located within walking distance to downtown beach and playground, you have easy access to all the activities in town. Walk or bike to the library, Resale Shop, Art in the Harbor, Baroque on Beaver events, grocery store, tennis courts, Community Center, restaurants, and more… Rentals available: Off Season Nightly Rentals – $185/night (3 night min.) Peak Season $1,200/week – rents Sun. to Sun.
Contact – Richards Rental Management Services (231) 675-6717 or email S.Richards.REALTOR@gmail.com
View Web Site E-mail

Located on a quiet 4 acres with 300’ of Lake Michigan frontage, this cottage & boat house is also a short 5 min bike ride or 10 min walk to town. Cabin – 3BRM (2 Queens, 3 Twins)plus couch bed, 1.5 BA, Boat house – 2 BRM (1 Queen, 2 Twins), 1 BA. Enjoy sunsets from the deck of the boat house, which offers a stunning view of three different islands. Home includes wireless internet and satellite TV, but the best option is to read a book on the screened-in porch while enjoying the peace and quiet. Peak Season $1,450/week(cabin) or $1,750(cabin & boathouse) – rents Sat. to Sat. (7 night min.) Off Season Nightly Rentals – Cabin – $175/night or $225/night (cabin & boat house) (4 night min.)
Contact – Richards Rental Management Services (231) 675-6717 or email S.Richards.REALTOR@gmail.com
View Web Page  E-mail

Isle Haven consists of four efficiency apartments with weekly rentals (Saturday to Saturday). Each apartment has two bedrooms complete with a full kitchen, bathroom and living room on one of the island’s most beautiful beaches and is located very close to town. In each apartment there is one bedroom with a double bed and the other has two single beds, with a futon in the living room that folds down to a double size bed. Please understand that there is a maximum of six people. All you really need to bring are sheets and towels since there are plenty of pillows and blankets in each apartment. Complimentary Wifi is available to all of our guests! A well mannered pet will be considered and accommodated with a nonrefundable $50.00 fee. Summer rentals are $700/week. There are weekly rentals only (Sat. to Sat.) June – August. Three day rentals are considered May, Sept. & Oct. (3 days $500). For more information or to make your reservation, please e-mail Marijean at: pikedut@yahoo.com or, you may call or text (231) 740-8551 View Web Page E-mail

Cozy and quaint, this 2 bed, 1 bathroom condo with sleeping for four is a perfect family getaway. One bedroom has a queen sized mattress and the other bedroom contains 2 single beds. The total square footage of the condo is roughly 750 sq. ft. The kitchen comes fully stocked for nice family dining. This semi-private property has log cabin exterior, private parking, patio with charcoal grill, TV, beach fire pit and the best views on the island.You’ll be within walking distance and/or biking distance to town which includes McDonough’s Market, Holy Cross Catholic Church, Toy Museum, Whiskey Point Lighthouse, Dalwhinnie’s Bakery, and of course Daddy Frank’s Ice Cream Parlor, just to name few.For those looking to get out and about, beautiful nature preserves and hiking trails can be found in and around the island. Kayaks and paddle boards can also be rented. Of course, the beach in front can keep children and adults busy all day as you watch boats come in and out, play games, swim, and enjoy the sweet sounds of the church bells or the waves rolling in as the sun settles in after a fun filled day.Renters must bring their own linens and towels and a $300.00 deposit will be collected upon making a reservation. Final payment due upon first day of rental. Weekly Rate: $750.00 – Memorial Day through Labor Day. Off season nightly rentals available at a lower rate. Cleaning fee: $50.00 Contact: Theresa Weber email: tawebe03@gmail.com
View Web Page E-mail

Lovely brand new (2014)above- garage apartment overlooking Font Lake.  Located 1 mile from town & tennis courts and 1 mile west to Donegal Bay public beach.  Sleeps 4 (1 bedroom with queen size bed and queen fold-out in LR).  One bath with walk-in shower.  Full kitchen, screened-in porch and open deck, WiFi and satellite TV included.  Apartment is on second story therefore not handicapped accessible.  Bring own sheets/towels.   $600/week, Sat-Sat rental,  $95/per night with 3-day rentals considered.  No smoking, no pets. Call Michael or Mary Beth Lyons 630-854-9052 or 630-854-9053. View Web Page  E-mail

Formerly Nolan’s Corner, This cozy cabin is on Johnson’s Point, within biking distance of the Library, Island Treasures Resale, Stony Acre Grill and downtown St. James. Nestled in a private woods, No Land, Just Sea sleeps 6 and up to 8 with extra rollaway beds, and includes linens, towels, and blankets. Equipped with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, has handicapped ramp, a full service kitchen (fridge, oven, dishwasher, microwave, coffeemaker, toaster), and a laundry room with washer and dryer, this cabin is perfect for your next family getaway. The open concept living area includes a stereo, phone for local calls, and TV with VCR, DVD and DirecTV. The cabin is stocked with books, puzzles, and family games for the occasional rainy day. The screened-in back porch with Adirondack chairs and a porch swing is the perfect place to enjoy a beautiful sunrise or dinner at the outdoor dining table. A view of the St. James Lighthouse and sailboats entering the bay provides for a peaceful afternoon watching the water. The backyard features a grill and firepit to BBQ or roast hot dogs. The cabin also has a wood burning stove for fall and winter visitors. $1,450/week. Contact-Richards Rental Management Services (231) 675-6717  View Web Page  E-mail

OWL#9 was completely remodeled in 2017 and 2018. A new custom maple kitchen was installed. Throughout, the unit is bright and cheery. There are two bedrooms and one bathroom. The master bed is a queen, and the second room has two twins. If you need more bed space, the living room futon makes another very comfortable double bed. We also provide linens for your use. The property provides free WiFi, and OWL#9 has a TV with DVD player (the public library has a good selection of DVDs), and cable TV is provided. Oak Woods Lodge is a newer condominium association that is located within walking distance of the Harbor District. Easy access to the boat, pubs, public beach, library, bike path, Community Center and more. Each unit contains a kitchenette and Wifi access. There is a common area in the center of the unit that is great for cookouts. Guests are welcome to use the gas grills. 2 Bedrooms (1 Queen, 2 Twins), Microwave, Stocked Kitchenette, newly remodeled. Short stays:
$165/night – 3 night minimum, Weekly Stay: ​$850/Week.
Contact Richards Rental Management Services (231) 675-6717  View Web Page  E-mail

New in 2008, this three bedroom (3 full baths) contemporary/craftsman cottage is located on Font Lake (one mile from St. James.) The property includes: sandy beach, wetlands with bridge and woods. The township park is adjacent to the home, where the bike path leads into town. It also includes Port of St. James common areas, hiking trails, and a private beach on Lake Michigan. A row boat and kayaks are included. Sleeps six in three queen size beds. Satellite TV with DVD player, radio, cd player, microwave, dishwasher, washer, dryer, weber gas grille, fully equipped kitchen, books, games, wifi and a gas fireplace. The home has two covered porches and two decks overlooking Font Lake. Please: No Pets and No Smoking. $1200/week includes linens, blankets, and pillows. Call (231) 448-2615. View Web Page E-mail

Located in the Harbor district of Beaver Island, just past the St James Boat Shop and McDonough’s Market. This cozy, historic home has a beautiful view of the harbor. Spend all day in the hammock, or visit the nearby museum, lighthouse, toy store, and deli. It’s an easy walk downtown for more restaurants, museums, shopping, and beaches with kayaks and paddleboards for rent. The home is ideal for a large family or multiple families. The first bedroom has a king bed and 2 twins. The second bedroom has a queen bed and 2 twins. The master bedroom has a queen bed and satellite television. Linens included Living room has satellite television, DVD, and stereo, game room has a satellite television, xbox, and fireplace. The kitchen is well equipped with coffee maker, toaster, microwave, stove, dishwasher, 2 full size refrigerators, and ice maker. WiFi is available throughout the house and large yard. Gas grill for barbecues. Washer and dryer is included. A cozy screened in porch is a great place to enjoy your morning coffee with a beautiful view of the harbor. Weekly rentals Memorial weekend thru Labor Day $1400/week, off season rentals $175/night, $1100/week.
Contact Rose Cole; (231) 459-5598 View Web Page E-mail

Located 4 blocks from the ferry dock overlooking your own sandy beach on the north shore. Play Outside SLEEPS EIGHT, and has 3 bedrooms with 5 beds. See photos, rates, reservation calendar + list of amenities at playoutsidebeachhouse.com. INSIDE: Two bedrooms on the main floor (at opposite ends of the house) each with a queen size bed. The third bedroom is downstairs and has 1 full size bed & 2 twin beds. Two full bathrooms on main floor; one en suite with a second vanity and walk-in closet. Bed & bath linens are provided with a mid-week “fresh towel exchange”. The great room has a fully equipped kitchen, comfortable living room seating, WiFi, Smart TV, Netflix, board games and books. OUTSIDE: There’s a gas grill, patio table & chairs on the deck. Beach toys, yard games and 2 adult bikes are provided. Roast marshmallows around the bonfire pit on the beach while you watch the sunset! No smoking and no pets. Contact Rene at (231) 313-0102 or playoutsidebeachhouse@gmail.com to make reservations.
(231) 313-0102 View Web Page E-mail

Formerly ENNISMORE. With an amazing Paradise Bay harbor view and private beach, situated just south of St. James and within quick walking distance to the boat dock and all harbor activities, this home is the perfect combination of everything that makes visiting Beaver Island the perfect family vacation. Ennismore consists of: 1,750sf of newly furnished living space, large living room with wood burning fireplace and a view of the lighthouse and harbor, large dining room with a view of the lighthouse and harbor,full size kitchen is perfect for cooking and entertaining and has a microwave, coffee maker, toaster, pots & pans, and large side by side refrigerator, sleeping accommodations for 8 – 10 (2 private bedrooms w queen size beds, large bunk room), covered porch and outdoor deck space with gas grill, his and her mountain bikes, private beach w lounging deck, lower level laundry room with washer and dryer, linens and bath towels are provided. No smoking or pets please. Memorial Day thru Labor Day weekly rental only (Saturday 3pm to Saturday 10am). $1,600.00 off season: 1,050.00 per week or $500.00 Friday thru Sunday. Please email or call with questions or to reserve your rental.
Phone: (765) 977-7236. email:sfelix@live.com View Web Page E-mail

If you’re looking for a Beaver Island getaway with a delicate blend of seclusion and convenience, look no further. This newly-constructed 3000-sqare foot cabin is located on the north end of the Island, nestled in a wooded setting, adjacent to a nature preserve. Less than one mile from the Boat Dock and yards away from 350 feet of pristine Lake Michigan waterfront, you and your family can enjoy the best of both Beaver Island worlds. The cabin includes comfortable sleeping accommodations: 5 bedrooms with 3 queen beds and 4 sets of bunk beds, a portable crib, and 2 full bathrooms. A cozy loft overlooks the spacious living room, complete with a TV, DVD player, and wood-burning fireplace. Other amenities include a ping pong table, fully furnished kitchen (including dishwasher and microwave), and washer/dryer. Bath towels and linens are included.
$1,850 per week (June through Labor Day) for parties of 8 or less. Parties larger than 8 please contact owner for rate. Four day minimum with a deposit required. No pets and no smoking. Off season rates available.
Contact Jean McDonough at (231) 675-5437 or email Jean McDonough at sjmcdonough@charter.net
View Web Page E-mail

Fabulous little home available in the off-season (from mid-September through mid June). The Townhouse is located just outside of the central Harbor District. Within walking distance to shops, the school, library, Community Center, and local pubs. 2 Bedrooms (1 Queen bed – 1 Double bed – 1 Twin bed), 1 Bathroom, Fully equipped kitchen with coffee maker, toaster, and microwave, Flat screened TV/WIFI, Books, games, a few DVD’s, Washer and Dryer available for guests use, Gas grill. Linens provided! In the back yard there is a campfire pit for roasting s’mores and enjoying a bit of wooded privacy. The public beach is located just a block away. Nightly Rentals – $95/night (2 night minimum) Weekly Rate – $350 1st week, plus $175 for each additional week Peak Season – Weekly rate – $700/week
Contact Richards Rental Management Services (231) 675-6717  View Web Page  E-mail

Scroll to Top